The European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA) recently drew attention to concerns about clearing access for smaller derivatives users. In a July 2016 consultation paper, it notes that “certain financial counterparties with a limited volume of activity appear to be facing difficulties in getting access to … clearing”. In response, ESMA has proposed more time for these entities to implement the clearing mandate.
The issue of clearing access for smaller derivatives users in the US has also been raised as a concern. To further examine these issues, ISDA conducted an analysis of publicly available data on clearing. The Association also surveyed and held discussions with small derivatives users in both the US and European Union (EU).
Among our findings:
- Over the past 18 months, there have been significant changes in the market share and the level of required client segregated funds for cleared swaps held by the top US futures commission merchants (FCMs). These changes likely reflect FCM business model shifts due to the impact of new capital requirements, as well as rising operational costs.
- As a result, some derivatives users have faced dislocation from their existing FCMs, and have needed to establish new FCM relationships in order to continue using swaps that are mandated for clearing.
- While it appears they have largely been successful in doing so, their costs are increasing, as FCMs impose minimum revenue thresholds for their swaps clearing clients.
- Monthly mandatory minimum clearing fees or minimum revenue thresholds appear to be standard among larger clearing members in the EU and are increasingly common in the US.
- In Europe, where there is no exemption from clearing for small financial end users (as there is in the US), these fees will be especially significant. ISDA’s analysis indicates the fees will range from $100,000 to $280,000 per year.
- It is difficult to precisely determine the total clearing costs that will be incurred in aggregate by small derivatives users based in the EU. ESMA estimates there are approximately 5,500 Category 3 financial counterparties. But a number of these are likely to be individual accounts managed by large asset managers that would not be subject to monthly minimums.
Documents (1) for Key Trends in Clearing for Small Derivatives Users
Latest
Updated OTC Derivatives Compliance Calendar
ISDA has updated its global calendar of compliance deadlines and regulatory dates for the over-the-counter (OTC) derivatives space.
A Positive Step to Improve the FRTB in the EU
As the Basel III capital reforms are finalized for implementation in key jurisdictions, ISDA is maintaining a laser focus on making sure the rules are robust and risk-appropriate. Simply put, if capital requirements are set disproportionately high, this will have...
Trading Book Capital: Scott O'Malia Remarks
Trading Book Capital: Policy Challenges for the EU 2024-2029 Mandate March 25, 2025 Welcoming Remarks Scott O’Malia ISDA Chief Executive Officer Good morning and welcome to ISDA’s trading book capital event. It’s great to be here in Brussels and...
Setting Out the Value Proposition of Derivatives
History enthusiasts may have heard of the Code of Hammurabi, an early legal text from ancient Mesopotamia, carved into a stone slab about 3,700 years ago. The code covers everything from property rights to divorce, but it also recognizes the...