
ISDA Chief Executive Officer Scott O'Malia offers informal comments on important OTC derivatives issues in derivatiViews, reflecting ISDA's long-held commitment to making the market safer and more efficient.
Anniversaries are important. They provide an opportunity to look back on important events in the past, and consider how they shaped the present. Ten years on from the collapse of Lehman Brothers, it’s therefore natural that people think back on what happened and ask what has changed.
The answer is: quite a lot. Consider the progress made in implementing the Group-of-20 derivatives market reforms. A key feature was the central clearing of standardized derivatives. Today, approximately 75% of total interest rate derivatives notional outstanding is cleared, mitigating bilateral counterparty credit risk.
Capital levels have increased significantly. The largest global banks have bolstered Tier 1 capital to the tune of €1.5 trillion since 2009, and bank liquidity profiles have significantly improved. Unlike 2008, formal processes for recovery and resolution are now in place in the event a bank fails.
According to the Financial Stability Board (FSB), 19 out of the 24 FSB countries have derivatives trade reporting mandates in place. Mandatory margin requirements are also being phased in, significantly reducing the risk of losses from the default of a counterparty.
But, 10 years on from the collapse of Lehman Brothers, now’s the time to ask what’s working, what’s not and what can be made better.
ISDA has worked to highlight areas where improvements can be made, and to suggest solutions to implementation challenges. The most important is the cross-border harmonization of rule sets. On capital, for instance, we’ve highlighted the need for local regulators to aim as far as possible for global consistency when implementing the Basel framework. A lack of harmonization would create impediments for internationally active firms, reducing the efficiency of markets and increasing compliance costs.
Consistency and cooperation are also important in regulatory reporting. It makes little sense for different jurisdictions to have their own reporting requirements and data formats. This needlessly increases the compliance burden for derivatives users, while reducing the ability of regulators to aggregate exposures on a global basis and spot the early signs of another financial crisis.
Another key issue is calibrating the rules to ensure they are risk-appropriate. For example, we’ve highlighted the challenges that will emerge in September 2020, when the threshold for compliance with initial margin requirements for non-cleared derivatives reduces from €750 billion to just €8 billion – a change ISDA estimates will capture more than 1,000 additional smaller banks and buy-side firms. In response, we’ve flagged the need to prepare early, and published guidance on the steps in-scope firms will need to take to comply.
These are just a couple of the issues still outstanding. It was important that we learned the lessons from Lehman and implemented changes to ensure the financial system is more resilient. But it’s also important we learn the lessons from the past 10 years, and refine and improve the rules where necessary to ensure the derivatives market remains both safe and efficient.
Latest
ISDA Response to EC on Environmental Legislation
On September 10, ISDA, the Association for Financial Markets in Europe (AFME) and the European Fund and Asset Management Association (EFAMA) submitted a joint response to the European Commission’s (EC) call for evidence on reducing the administrative burden in environmental...
Credit Derivatives Trading Activity Q2 2025
This report analyzes credit derivatives trading activity reported in Europe. The analysis shows European credit derivatives transactions based on the location of reporting venues (EU versus UK) and product type. The report also compares European-reported credit derivatives trading activity to...
ISDA Trading and Treasury Forum: CEO Remarks
ISDA Derivatives Trading and Treasury Forum London, September 16, 2025 Opening Remarks Scott O’Malia ISDA Chief Executive Officer Good morning, and welcome to the ISDA Derivatives Trading and Treasury Forum. Thank you to CME Group for partnering with us...
Recognition of Cross-product Netting is Critical
US regulators are in the process of making important changes to the regulatory capital framework by proposing modifications to the enhanced supplementary leverage ratio, which should help stop it from acting as a non-risk-sensitive constraint on bank capacity – a...